HomeBlog Home
Tips & Advice

6 Red Flags You Should Watch for in an HOA

Brian Lee BurkeBrian Lee Burke
Apr 17, 2025 3 min read
Share to X
Share to Facebook
Share to Linkedin
Copy Link
6 Red Flags You Should Watch for in an HOA

A piece of paper titled "Homeowners Association" sitting next to a blue highlighter, wooden home cutouts, and a book.

Most homes belong to HOAs. Therefore, these community organizations should be top of mind for homebuyers. An HOA should make your home’s community nicer and easier to live in. However, that is unfortunately not the case for many of them. If you enter into a disorganized, toxic HOA, you could be in for years of stress and frustration. We’re here to teach you the red flags to watch for in an HOA so you can invest confidently in the right property.

1. Lack of Transparency

A well-run HOA should provide clear access to meeting minutes, financial records, and governing documents. If they’re hesitant or unwilling to share this information, that’s a major red flag. Transparency is key to understanding how the HOA operates, what rules and restrictions you’ll face, and how your dues are allocated.

2. Excessively High or Low HOA Fees

While HOA fees vary based on location and amenities, homeowners need to determine whether the costs align with the services provided.

High fees might seem alarming, but they’re sometimes necessary for well-maintained amenities and a robust reserve fund. However, excessively high fees without corresponding benefits may signal mismanagement or unnecessary spending.

Equally concerning are fees that seem unusually low. This could point to a lack of maintenance, inadequate reserve funds, or future assessments for unexpected repairs.

3. Poorly Maintained Community Spaces

The condition of shared spaces speaks volumes about an HOA’s competency. Walk through the property and carefully examine common areas, such as parks, clubhouses, pools, landscaping, and parking lots.

If you notice, for example, that the association hasn’t implemented drainage solutions for playground flooring, leaving the area riddled with standing water, take note. Likewise, if you see that most or all of the green areas are overgrown, the association isn’t keeping up with basic maintenance.

Poorly maintained common spaces don’t just impact your quality of life; they can also lower your property’s value and impose additional repair costs. An HOA prioritizing regular maintenance and cleanliness upholds your property’s value and community satisfaction.

4. Excessive Rules and Restrictions

HOAs are intended to foster harmony within the community, so they set rules. This is normal, but watch out for excessive or overly restrictive regulations. Overreaching rules about everything from paint colors to lawn decorations will probably be more annoying than useful. Additionally, excessively punitive enforcement of these rules can lead to conflicts with the HOA board.

5. Insufficient Reserve Fund

An HOA’s reserve fund is for covering major repairs and unexpected expenses, such as roof replacements or infrastructure updates. If the reserve fund is insufficient or poorly managed, residents could face unexpected assessments or significant fee increases. Some associations consider options for funding community repairs to avoid sudden assessments. A well-funded reserve is a sign of a financially stable HOA prepared to handle long-term obligations and make the most of your dues.

Make an Informed Decision on Your Home Purchase

If you buy a home in an HOA, then that organization will affect your experience living in the community. By watching for these red flags, you can feel confident in your homebuying decision and step into a supportive, well-run community.

Contact Kenna Real Estate Group

WRITTEN BY
Brian Lee Burke
Brian Lee Burke
Team Owner, REALTOR®, Author, E-PRO®,

Brian Lee Burke is the founder and team leader of Kenna Real Estate Group, a real estate team at Keller Williams DTC. A licensed REALTOR® since 2002, Brian helps Colorado buyers and sellers navigate residential real estate, new construction, pricing, and negotiation. He is also the author of The Real Estate Playbook and Mastering Real Estate: Your Guide to Becoming a Top Agent.

View Brian Lee Burke’s full profile.